Matt XStatic vs Marc Anthony, 22 July 2011 (All Star Wrestling)
After suffering through the best the bad guy has to offer (see above), Matt XStatic, in his spectacular ASW debut, knocks Mark Anthony off his high horse. It's a stunning upset, catching the crowd offguard and flat-out destroying the tough baldy. And he does it on his own, the ref doing the babyface no favors. It's all good for fans, like me, who revel in swift, hard, merciless comeuppance. It goes without saying that the GIFs tell a less complicated version of the actual story, but these are the moments that stick in my imagination.
That finisher is something else! (Oh, and the homophobes in the audience are dicks.)
The match on YouTube is split into two parts. Part two is here.